Srinagar, Nov 16 (KNO): The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) of India has pointed out an alleged irregularity in the implementation of the Direct Tax Vivad Se Vishwas Scheme, 2020, in Jammu and Kashmir, with a Srinagar-based private company figuring among the cases where benefits were reportedly granted despite non-fulfilment of eligibility criteria.
As per CAG Report No. 8 of 2026, accessed by the news agency—Kashmir News Observer (KNO), the case involves V1 Pvt. Ltd., registered under the jurisdiction of the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (PCIT), Srinagar, for the assessment year 2017-18. The audit has quantified the tax impact of the case at Rs 4.17 lakh.
The Srinagar case is among 17 instances identified by the national audit authority across 11 states, involving a combined tax effect of Rs 6.96 crore. In these cases, the Income Tax Department allegedly allowed taxpayers to avail benefits under the scheme despite their ineligibility.
Listed at serial number 16 in Annexure 5.8 of the report, the Srinagar-based firm's identity has been partially withheld, with the audit document referring to it as V1 Pvt. Ltd. The report, however, does not elaborate on the specific circumstances or grounds behind the irregularity in this particular case.
The audit report has also presented data regarding the participation of Jammu and Kashmir taxpayers in the scheme. According to the figures, a total of 585 applications were received from the Union Territory, of which nine cases, accounting for around 1.5 per cent, were selected for detailed scrutiny.
These nine cases were part of a nationwide audit sample comprising 5,335 cases drawn from an overall pool of 1,48,366 applications. Jammu and Kashmir's share in the total applications stood at approximately 0.39 per cent.
At the national level, the CAG examined 5,212 cases and detected violations of the provisions of the Direct Tax Vivad Se Vishwas Act and Rules in 389 instances, resulting in a revenue impact of Rs 1,675.65 crore.
The reported deficiencies included incorrect computation of disputed tax and payable amounts, non-recovery of interest paid to assessees, errors in calculating tax liabilities in search-related cases and granting scheme benefits to taxpayers who did not meet the prescribed conditions.
Apart from these irregularities, the audit flagged delays in application processing, deficiencies in maintaining records and weaknesses in the department's monitoring and information technology systems.
The CAG has called for stronger oversight by the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT), uniform implementation of the scheme's provisions and improved internal controls to prevent recurrence of such discrepancies—(KNO)